All news

News

Facebook sent this Troy woman goat ads, then a scam followed

Facebook sent this Troy woman goat ads, then a scam followed

WXYZ-TV reports Troy police say the Chime account loaded with cash at CVS, used to pay the goat scammer, is a common and recognised method.

20 November 2026

Key facts

Doris Plantus, 72, lost more than $1,700 to a fake goat listing Seller demanded $1,250 more after claiming a family emergency Seller threatened her with an animal abandonment charge Payment was sent via Chime, loaded with cash at CVS

Reported by

WXYZ-TV

A Facebook Marketplace listing for miniature goats led a Troy woman to send more than $1,700 to a scammer who never delivered the animals. Troy police say the payment method the scammer pushed, a Chime account loaded with cash at CVS, is a standard tactic, not an unusual one. If a seller demands payment through a cash-loading app or threatens legal trouble for not paying more, stop the conversation and report the listing.

As reported by WXYZ-TV, the listing reached 72-year-old Doris Plantus shortly after she had been talking about goats near her phone. She noticed ads for goats appearing on her Facebook feed afterward, and took it as a sign Facebook's own targeting had surfaced the listing to her.

How the goats never arrived

Plantus had just lost one of her two goats, Theo, and wanted a new companion for the surviving one, Raphael. A Marketplace listing offered two goats for $499, with the seller promising personal delivery from Pennsylvania. She paid. Then the story shifted: the seller said his wife had gone into labor and the goats were stuck at a shipping facility. He asked for $1,250 more, for crates, vet screenings and goat tags.

When Plantus hesitated, the seller told her she could be charged with animal abandonment and that her existing pets could be taken away. That threat is what moved the money. She paid through Chime, directed there by the seller, and was told to go to CVS so staff could help her load funds into the account. Her bank flagged the charges as fraudulent afterward. She reported it to Troy police. The goats never existed.

Sgt. John Julian of the Troy Police Department said the case is unusual in its details but ordinary in its method. Fear, urgency and a push toward a specific payment app are the pattern, regardless of what is being sold. A legitimate seller does not threaten a buyer with legal consequences for declining to pay more.

Facebook Marketplace puts buyers in direct contact with unverified sellers and lets payment move outside any platform protection, straight to a third-party app a seller names. The listing reached Plantus through the same ad-targeting system that shows her other things she has mentioned near her phone, which means the same system that personalizes her feed also delivered the scam. Nothing in the account of what happened describes Facebook reviewing the listing or flagging the payment request as it moved toward a cash-loading app.

Check a message

Received something like this? Paste it into the Flggd message checker before you reply, click or pay.

Related stories

What to do

  • Stop paying once a seller asks for money beyond the original price.
  • Treat threats of legal trouble from a private seller as a red flag, not a reason to pay.
  • Check any claim about fees or charges using a source you already trust, not the seller.
  • Report the listing to Facebook and to local police, as Plantus did with Troy police.